Warning: Illegal string offset 'is_jump' in /www/wwwroot/www/app/fxs/controller/chapter.php on line 244
The Spirit of Laws
投诉 阅读记录

第7章

PhaleasofChalcedon[10]contrivedaveryextraordinarymethodofrenderingallfortunesequal,inarepublicwheretherewasthegreatestinequality。Thiswasthattherichshouldgivefortuneswiththeirdaughterstothepoor,butreceivenonethemselves;andthatthepoorshouldreceivemoneyfortheirdaughters,insteadofgivingthemfortunes。ButIdonotrememberthataregulationofthiskindevertookplaceinanyrepublic。Itlaysthecitizensundersuchhardandoppressiveconditionsaswouldmakethemdetesttheveryequalitywhichtheydesignedtoestablish。Itispropersometimesthatthelawsshouldnotseemtotendsodirectlytotheendtheypropose。

Thoughrealequalitybetheverysoulofademocracy,itissodifficulttoestablishthatanextremeexactnessinthisrespectwouldnotbealwaysconvenient。Sufficientisittoestablishacensus[11]whichshallreduceorfixthedifferencestoacertainpoint:itisafterwardsthebusinessofparticularlawstolevel,asitwere,theinequalities,bythedutieslaidupontherich,andbytheeaseaffordedtothepoor。

Itismoderaterichesalonethatcangiveorsufferthissortofcompensation;forastomenofovergrownestates,everythingwhichdoesnotcontributetoadvancetheirpowerandhonourisconsideredbythemasaninjury。

Allinequalityindemocraciesoughttobederivedfromthenatureofthegovernment,andevenfromtheprincipleofequality。Forexample,itmaybeapprehendedthatpeoplewhoareobligedtolivebytheirlabourwouldbetoomuchimpoverishedbyapublicemployment,orneglectthedutiesattendingit;thatartisanswouldgrowinsolent,andthattoogreatanumberoffreemenwouldoverpowertheancientcitizens。Inthiscasetheequality[12]inademocracymaybesuppressedforthegoodofthestate。

Butthisisonlyanapparentequality;foramanruinedbyapublicemploymentwouldbeinaworseconditionthanhisfellow—citizens;andthissameman,beingobligedtoneglecthisduty,wouldreducetheresttoaworseconditionthanhimself,andsoon。

6。InwhatMannertheLawsoughttomaintainFrugalityinaDemocracy。

Itisnotsufficientinawell—regulateddemocracythatthedivisionsoflandbeequal;theyoughtalsotobesmall,aswascustomaryamongtheRomans。"Godforbid,"saidCuriustohissoldiers,[13]"thatacitizenshouldlookuponthatasasmallpieceoflandwhichissufficienttomaintainhim。"

Asequalityoffortunessupportsfrugality,sothelattermaintainstheformer。Thesethings,thoughinthemselvesdifferent,areofsuchanatureastobeunabletosubsistseparately;theyreciprocallyactuponeachother;ifonewithdrawsitselffromademocracy,theothersurelyfollowsit。

Trueisitthatwhenademocracyisfoundedoncommerce,privatepeoplemayacquirevastricheswithoutacorruptionofmorals。

Thisisbecausethespiritofcommerceisnaturallyattendedwiththatoffrugality,economy,moderation,labour,prudence,tranquillity,order,andrule。Solongasthisspiritsubsists,therichesitproduceshavenobadeffect。Themischiefis,whenexcessivewealthdestroysthespiritofcommerce,thenitisthattheinconveniencesofinequalitybegintobefelt。

Inordertosupportthisspirit,commerceshouldbecarriedonbytheprincipalcitizens;thisshouldbetheirsoleaimandstudy;thisthechiefobjectofthelaws:andtheseverylaws,bydividingtheestatesofindividualsinproportiontotheincreaseofcommerce,shouldseteverypoorcitizensofarathiseaseastobeabletoworkliketherest,andeverywealthycitizeninsuchamediocrityastobeobligedtotakesomepainseitherinpreservingoracquiringafortune。

Itisanexcellentlawinatradingrepublictomakeanequaldivisionofthepaternalestateamongthechildren。Theconsequenceofthisisthathowgreatsoeverafortunethefatherhasmade,hischildren,beingnotsorichashe,areinducedtoavoidluxury,andtoworkashehasdone。Ispeakhereonlyoftradingrepublics;astothosethathavenocommerce,thelegislatormustpursuequitedifferentmeasures。[14]

InGreecethereweretwosortsofrepublics:theonemilitary,likeSparta;theothercommercial,asAthens。Intheformer,thecitizenswereobligedtobeidle;inthelatter,endeavourswereusedtoinspirethemwiththeloveofindustryandlabour。Solonmadeidlenessacrime,andinsistedthateachcitizenshouldgiveanaccountofhismannerofgettingalivelihood。And,indeed,inawell—regulateddemocracy,wherepeople’sexpensesshouldextendonlytowhatisnecessary,everyoneoughttohaveit;forhowshouldtheirwantsbeotherwisesupplied?

7。OtherMethodsoffavouringthePrincipleofDemocracy。Anequaldivisionoflandscannotbeestablishedinalldemocracies。Therearesomecircumstancesinwhicharegulationofthisnaturewouldbeimpracticable,dangerous,andevensubversiveoftheconstitution。Wearenotalwaysobligedtoproceedtoextremes。Ifitappearsthatthisdivisionoflands,whichwasdesignedtopreservethepeople’smorals,doesnotsuitthedemocracy,recoursemustbehadtoothermethods。

Ifapermanentbodybeestablishedtoserveasaruleandpatternofmanners;asenate,towhichyears,virtue,gravity,andeminentservicesprocureadmittance;thesenators,bybeingexposedtopublicviewlikethestatuesofthegods,mustnaturallyinspireeveryfamilywithsentimentsofvirtue。

Aboveall,thissenatemuststeadilyadheretotheancientinstitutions,andmindthatthepeopleandthemagistratesneverswervefromthem。

Thepreservationoftheancientcustomsisaveryconsiderablepointinrespecttomanners。Sinceacorruptpeopleseldomperformanymemorableactions,seldomestablishsocieties,buildcities,orenactlaws;onthecontrary,sincemostinstitutionsarederivedfrompeoplewhosemannersareplainandsimple,tokeepuptheancientcustomsisthewaytopreservetheoriginalpurityofmorals。

Besides,ifbysomerevolutionthestatehashappenedtoassumeanewform,thisseldomcanbeeffectedwithoutinfinitepainsandlabour,andhardlyeverbyidleanddebauchedpersons。Eventhosewhohadbeentheinstrumentsoftherevolutionweredesirousitshouldberelished,whichisdifficulttocompasswithoutgoodlaws。Henceitisthatancientinstitutionsgenerallytendtoreformthepeople’smanners,andthoseofmoderndatetocorruptthem。Inthecourseofalongadministration,thedescenttoviceisinsensible;butthereisnoreascendingtovirtuewithoutmakingthemostgenerousefforts。

Ithasbeenquestionedwhetherthemembersofthesenatewearespeakingofoughttobeforlifeoronlychosenforatime。Doubtlesstheyoughttobeforlife,aswasthecustomatRome,[15]atSparta,[16]andevenatAthens。ForwemustnotconfoundthesenateatAthens,whichwasabodythatchangedeverythreemonths,withtheAreopagus,whosemembers,asstandingpatterns,wereestablishedforlife。

Letthisbethereforeageneralmaxim;thatinasenatedesignedtobearule,andthedepository,asitwere,ofmanners,themembersoughttobechosenforlife:inasenateintendedfortheadministrationofaffairs,themembersmaybechanged。

Thespirit,saysAristotle,waxesoldaswellasthebody。Thisreflectionholdsgoodonlyinregardtoasinglemagistrate,butcannotbeappliedtoasenatorialassembly。

AtAthens,besidestheAreopagus,therewereguardiansofthepublicmorals,aswellasofthelaws。[17]AtSparta,alltheoldmenwerecensors。AtRome,thecensorshipwascommittedtotwoparticularmagistrates。Asthesenatewatchedoverthepeople,thecensorsweretohaveaneyeoverthepeopleandthesenate。Theirofficewastoreformthecorruptionsoftherepublic,tostigmatiseindolence,tocensureneglects,andtocorrectmistakes;astoflagrantcrimes,thesewerelefttothepunishmentofthelaws。

ThatRomanlawwhichrequiredtheaccusationsincasesofadulterytobepublicwasadmirablywellcalculatedforpreservingthepurityofmorals;itintimidatedmarriedwomen,aswellasthosewhoweretowatchovertheirconduct。

Nothingcontributesmoretothepreservationofmoralsthananextremesubordinationoftheyoungtotheold。Thustheyarebothrestrained,theformerbytheirrespectforthoseofadvancedage,andthelatterbytheirregardforthemselves。

Nothinggivesagreaterforcetothelawthanaperfectsubordinationbetweenthecitizensandthemagistrate。"ThegreatdifferencewhichLycurgusestablishedbetweenSpartaandtheothercities,"saysXenophon,[18]"consistschieflyintheobediencethecitizensshowtotheirlaws;theyrunwhenthemagistratecallsthem。ButatAthensarichmanwouldbehighlydispleasedtobethoughtdependentonthemagistrate。"

Paternalauthorityislikewiseofgreatusetowardsthepreservationofmorals。Wehavealreadyobservedthatinarepublicthereisnotsocoerciveaforceasinothergovernments。Thelawsmustthereforeendeavourtosupplythisdefectbysomemeansorother;andthisisdonebypaternalauthority。

FathersatRomehadthepoweroflifeanddeathovertheirchildren。[19]

AtSparta,everyfatherhadarighttocorrectanotherman’schild。

PaternalauthorityendedatRometogetherwiththerepublic。Inmonarchies,wheresuchapurityofmoralsisnotrequired,theyarecontrolledbynootherauthoritythanthatofthemagistrates。

TheRomanlaws,whichaccustomedyoungpeopletodependence,establishedalongminority。Perhapswearemistakeninconformingtothiscustom;

thereisnonecessityforsomuchconstraintinmonarchies。

Thisverysubordinationinarepublicmightmakeitnecessaryforthefathertocontinueinthepossessionofhischildren’sfortuneduringlife,aswasthecustomatRome。Butthisisnotagreeabletothespiritofmonarchy。

8。InwhatMannertheLawsshouldrelatetothePrincipleofGovernmentinanAristocracy。Ifthepeoplearevirtuousinanaristocracy,theyenjoyverynearlythesamehappinessasinapopulargovernment,andthestategrowspowerful。Butasagreatshareofvirtueisveryrarewheremen’sfortunesaresounequal,thelawsmusttendasmuchaspossibletoinfuseaspiritofmoderation,andendeavourtore—establishthatequalitywhichwasnecessarilyremovedbytheconstitution。

Thespiritofmoderationiswhatwecallvirtueinanaristocracy;itsuppliestheplaceofthespiritofequalityinapopularstate。

Asthepompandsplendourwithwhichkingsaresurroundedformapartoftheirpower,somodestyandsimplicityofmannersconstitutethestrengthofanaristocraticnobility。[20]Whentheyaffectnodistinction,whentheymixwiththepeople,dresslikethem,andwiththemsharealltheirpleasures,thepeopleareapttoforgettheirsubjectionandweakness。

Everygovernmenthasitsnatureandprinciple。Anaristocracymustnotthereforeassumethenatureandprincipleofmonarchy;whichwouldbethecasewerethenoblestobeinvestedwithpersonalprivilegesdistinctfromthoseoftheirbody;privilegesoughttobeforthesenate,andsimplerespectforthesenators。

Inaristocraticgovernmentstherearetwoprincipalsourcesofdisorder:

excessiveinequalitybetweenthegovernorsandthegoverned;andthesameinequalitybetweenthedifferentmembersofthebodythatgoverns。

Fromthesetwoinequalities,hatredsandjealousiesarise,whichthelawsoughtevertopreventorrepress。

Thefirstinequalityischieflywhentheprivilegesofthenobilityarehonourableonlyastheyareignominioustothepeople。SuchwasthelawatRomebywhichthepatricianswereforbiddentomarryplebeians;[21]alawthathadnoothereffectthantorenderthepatriciansontheonesidemorehaughty,andontheothermoreodious。Thereadermayseewhatadvantagesthetribunesderivedthenceintheirharangues。

Thisinequalityoccurslikewisewhentheconditionofthecitizensdifferswithregardtotaxes,whichmayhappeninfourdifferentways:

whenthenoblesassumetheprivilegeofpayingnone;whentheycommitfraudstoexemptthemselves;[22]whentheyengrossthepublicmoney,underpretenceofrewardsorappointmentsfortheirrespectiveemployments;infine,whentheyrenderthecommonpeopletributary,anddivideamongtheirownbodytheprofitsarisingfromtheseveralsubsidies。Thislastcaseisveryrare;anaristocracysoinstitutedwouldbethemostintolerableofallgovernments。

WhileRomeinclinedtowardsaristocracy,sheavoidedalltheseinconveniences。Themagistratesneverreceivedanyemolumentsfromtheiroffice。Thechiefmenoftherepublicweretaxedliketherest,nay,moreheavily;andsometimesthetaxesfelluponthemalone。Infine,farfromsharingamongthemselvestherevenuesofthestate,alltheycoulddrawfromthepublictreasure,andallthewealththatfortuneflungintotheirlaps,theybestowedfreelyonthepeople,tobeexcusedfromacceptingpublichonours。[23]

Itisafundamentalmaximthatlargessesarepernicioustothepeopleinademocracy,butsalutaryinanaristocraticgovernment。Theformermakethemforgettheyarecitizens,thelatterbringthemtoasenseofit。

Iftherevenuesofthestatearenotdistributedamongthepeople,theymustbeconvincedatleastoftheirbeingwelladministered:tofeasttheireyeswiththepublictreasureiswiththemthesamethingalmostasenjoyingit。ThegoldenchaindisplayedatVenice,therichesexhibitedatRomeinpublictriumphs,thetreasurespreservedinthetempleofSaturn,wereinrealitythewealthofthepeople。

Itisaveryessentialpointinanaristocracythatthenoblesthemselvesshouldnotlevythetaxes。ThefirstorderofthestateinRomeneverconcernedthemselveswithit;thelevyingofthetaxeswascommittedtothesecond,andeventhisinprocessoftimewasattendedwithgreatinconveniences。Inanaristocracyofthiskind,wherethenoblesleviedthetaxes,theprivatepeoplewouldbeallatthediscretionofpersonsinpublicemployments;andtherewouldbenosuchthingasasuperiortribunaltochecktheirpower。Themembersappointedtoremovetheabuseswouldratherenjoythem。Thenobleswouldbeliketheprincesofdespoticgovernments,whoconfiscatewhateverestatestheyplease。

Soonwouldtheprofitshencearisingbeconsideredasapatrimony,whichavaricewouldenlargeatpleasure。Thefarmswouldbelowered,andthepublicrevenuesreducedtonothing。Thisisthereasonthatsomegovernments,withouthavingeverreceivedanyremarkableshock,havedwindledawaytosuchadegreeasnotonlytheirneighbours,buteventheirownsubjects,havebeensurprisedatit。

Thelawsshouldlikewiseforbidthenoblesallkindsofcommerce:

merchantsofsuchunboundedcreditwouldmonopolisealltothemselves。

Commerceisaprofessionofpeoplewhoareuponanequality;henceamongdespoticstatesthemostmiserablearethoseinwhichtheprinceapplieshimselftotrade。

ThelawsofVenicedebar[24]thenoblesfromcommerce,bywhichtheymighteveninnocentlyacquireexorbitantwealth。

Thelawsoughttoemploythemosteffectualmeansformakingthenoblesdojusticetothepeople。Iftheyhavenotestablishedatribune,theyoughttobeatribunethemselves。

Everysortofasyluminoppositiontotheexecutionofthelawsdestroysaristocracy,andissoonsucceededbytyranny。Theyoughtalwaystomortifythelustofdominion。Thereshouldbeeitheratemporaryorperpetualmagistratetokeepthenoblesinawe,astheEphoriatSpartaandtheStateInquisitorsatVenice——magistratessubjecttonoformalities。Thissortofgovernmentstandsinneedofthestrongestsprings:thusamouthofstone[25]isopentoeveryinformeratVenice——amouthtowhichonewouldbeapttogivetheappellationoftyranny。

Thesearbitrarymagistratesinanaristocracybearsomeanalogytothecensorshipindemocracies,whichofitsownnatureisequallyindependent。And,indeed,thecensorsoughttobesubjecttonoinquiryinrelationtotheirconductduringtheiroffice;theyshouldmeetwithathoroughconfidence,andneverbediscouraged。InthisrespectthepracticeoftheRomansdeservedadmiration;magistratesofalldenominationswereaccountablefortheiradministration,[26]exceptthecensors。[27]

Therearetwoveryperniciousthingsinanaristocracy——excesseitherofpoverty,orofwealthinthenobility。Topreventtheirpoverty,itisnecessary,aboveallthings,toobligethemtopaytheirdebtsintime。Tomoderatetheexcessofwealth,prudentandgradualregulationsshouldbemade;butnoconfiscations,noagrarianlaws,noexpungingofdebts;theseareproductiveofinfinitemischief。

Thelawsoughttoabolishtherightofprimogenitureamongthenobles[28]totheendthatbyacontinualdivisionoftheinheritancestheirfortunesmaybealwaysuponalevel。

Thereshouldbenosubstitutions,nopowersofredemption,norightsofMajorasgo,oradoption。Thecontrivancesforperpetuatingthegrandeuroffamiliesinmonarchicalgovernmentsoughtnevertobeemployedinaristocracies。[29]

Whenthelawshavecompassedtheequalityoffamilies,thenextthingistopreserveaproperharmonyandunionamongthem。Thequarrelsofthenobilityoughttobequicklydecided;otherwisethecontestsofindividualsbecomethoseoffamilies。Arbitersmayterminate,orevenprevent,theriseotdisputes。

Infine,thelawsmustnotfavourthedistinctionsraisedbyvanityamongfamilies,underpretencethattheyaremorenobleorancientthanothers。Pretencesofthisnatureoughttoberankedamongtheweaknessesofprivatepersons。

WehaveonlytocastaneyeuponSparta;therewemayseehowtheEphoricontrivedtocheckthefoiblesofthekings,aswellasthoseofthenobilityandcommonpeople。

9。InwhatMannertheLawsareinrelationtotheirPrincipleinMonarchies。Ashonouristheprincipleofamonarchicalgovernment,thelawsoughttobeinrelationtothisprinciple。

Theyshouldendeavourtosupportthenobility,inrespecttowhomhonourmaybe,insomemeasure,deemedbothchildandparent。

Theyshouldrenderthenobilityhereditary,notasaboundarybetweenthepoweroftheprinceandtheweaknessofthepeople,butasthelinkwhichconnectsthemboth。

Inthisgovernment,substitutionswhichpreservetheestatesoffamiliesundividedareextremelyuseful,thoughinothersnotsoproper。

Herethepowerofredemptionisofservice,asitrestorestonoblefamiliesthelandsthathadbeenalienatedbytheprodigalityofaparent。

Thelandofthenobilityoughttohaveprivilegesaswellastheirpersons。Themonarch’sdignityisinseparablefromthatofhiskingdom;

and—thedignityofthenoblemanfromthatofhisfief。

Alltheseprivilegesmustbepeculiartothenobility,andincommunicabletothepeople,unlessweintendtoactcontrarytotheprincipleofgovernment,andtodiminishthepowerofthenoblestogetherwiththatofthepeople。

Substitutionsarearestrainttocommerce,thepowerofredemptionproducesaninfinitenumberofprocesses;everyestateinlandthatissoldthroughoutthekingdomisinsomemeasurewithoutanownerforthespaceofayear。Privilegesannexedtofiefsgiveapowerveryburdensometothosegovernmentswhichtoleratethem。Thesearetheinconveniencesofnobility——inconveniences,however,thatvanishwhenconfrontedwithitsgeneralutility:butwhentheseprivilegesarecommunicatedtothepeople,everyprincipleofgovernmentiswantonlyviolated。

Inmonarchiesapersonmayleavethebulkofhisestatetooneofhischildren——apermissionimproperinanyothergovernment。

Thelawsoughttofavourallkindsofcommerce[30]consistentwiththeconstitution,totheendthatthesubjectsmay,withoutruiningthemselves,beabletosatisfythecontinualcravingsoftheprinceandhiscourt。

Theyshouldestablishsomeregulationthatthemannerofcollectingthetaxesmaynotbemoreburdensomethanthetaxesthemselves。

Theweightofdutiesproduceslabour,labourweariness,andwearinessthespiritofindolence。

10。OftheExpeditionpeculiartotheExecutivePowerinMonarchies。

Greatistheadvantagewhichamonarchicalgovernmenthasoverarepublic:asthestateisconductedbyasingleperson,theexecutivepoweristherebyenabledtoactwithgreaterexpedition。Butasthisexpeditionmaydegenerateintorapidity,thelawsshouldusesomecontrivancetoslackenit。Theyoughtnotonlytofavourthenatureofeachconstitution,butlikewisetoremedytheabusesthatmightresultfromthisverynature。

CardinalRichelieu[31]advisesmonarchstopermitnosuchthingsassocietiesorcommunitiesthatraisedifficultiesuponeverytrifle。Ifthisman’shearthadnotbeenbewitchedwiththeloveofdespoticpower,stillthesearbitrarynotionswouldhavefilledhishead。

Thebodiesentrustedwiththedepositionofthelawsarenevermoreobedientthanwhentheyproceedslowly,andusethatreflectionintheprince’saffairswhichcanscarcelybeexpectedfromtheignoranceofacourt,orfromtheprecipitationofitscouncils。[32]

Whatwouldhavebecomeofthefinestmonarchyintheworldifthemagistrates,bytheirdelays,theircomplaints,andentreaties,hadnotcheckedtherapidityevenoftheirprinces’virtues,whenthesemonarchs,consultingonlythegenerousimpulseoftheirminds,wouldfainhavegivenaboundlessrewardtoservicesperformedwithanunlimitedcourageandfidelity?

11。OftheExcellenceofaMonarchicalGovernment。Monarchyhasagreatadvantageoveradespoticgovernment。Asitnaturallyrequiresthereshouldbeseveralordersorranksofsubjects,thestateismorepermanent,theconstitutionmoresteady,andthepersonofhimwhogovernsmoresecure。

Ciceroisofopinionthattheestablishingofthetribunespreservedtherepublic。"Andindeed,"sayshe,"theviolenceofaheadlesspeopleismoreterrible。Achieforheadissensiblethattheaffairdependsuponhimself,andthereforehethinks;butthepeopleintheirimpetuosityareignorantofthedangerintowhichtheyhurrythemselves。"Thisreflectionmaybeappliedtoadespoticgovernment,whichisapeoplewithouttribunes;andtoamonarchy,wherethepeoplehavesomesortoftribunes。

Accordinglyitisobservablethatinthecommotionsofadespoticgovernment,thepeople,hurriedawaybytheirpassions,areapttopushthingsasfarastheycango。Thedisorderstheycommitareallextreme;

whereasinmonarchiesmattersareseldomcarriedtoexcess。Thechiefsareapprehensiveontheirownaccount;theyareafraidofbeingabandoned,andtheintermediatedependentpowersdonotchoosethatthepopulaceshouldhavetoomuchtheupperhand。Itrarelyhappensthatthestatesofthekingdomareentirelycorrupted:theprinceadherestothese;andtheseditious,whohaveneitherwillnorhopestosubvertthegovernment,haveneitherpowernorwilltodethronetheprince。

Inthesecircumstancesmenofprudenceandauthorityinterfere;moderatemeasuresarefirstproposed,thencompliedwith,andthingsatlengthareredressed;thelawsresumetheirvigour,andcommandsubmission。

Thusallourhistoriesarefullofcivilwarswithoutrevolutions,whilethehistoriesofdespoticgovernmentsaboundwithrevolutionswithoutcivilwars。

Thewritersofthehistoryofthecivilwarsofsomecountries,eventhosewhofomentedthem,sufficientlydemonstratethelittlefoundationprinceshavetosuspecttheauthoritywithwhichtheyinvestparticularbodiesofmen;since,evenundertheunhappycircumstanceoftheirerrors,theysighedonlyafterthelawsandtheirduty;andrestrained,morethantheywerecapableofinflaming,theimpetuosityoftherevolted。[33]CardinalRichelieu,reflectingperhapsthathehadtoomuchreducedthestatesofthekingdom,hasrecoursetothevirtuesoftheprinceandofhisministersforthesupport[34]ofgovernment:butherequiressomanythings,thatindeedthereisnonebutanangelcapableofsuchattention,suchresolutionandknowledge;andscarcelycanweflatterourselvesthatweshalleverseesuchaprinceandministerswhilemonarchysubsists。

Aspeoplewholiveunderagoodgovernmentarehappierthanthosewhowithoutruleorleaderswanderabouttheforests,somonarchswholiveunderthefundamentallawsoftheircountryarefarhappierthandespoticprinceswhohavenothingtoregulate,neithertheirownpassionsnorthoseoftheirsubjects。

12。ThesameSubjectcontinued。Letusnotlookformagnanimityindespoticgovernments;theprincecannotimpartagreatnesswhichhehasnothimself;withhimthereisnosuchthingasglory。

关闭